These are the standards evidence is judged against — published in full, so a score can always be traced back to the exact rule that produced it. Thresholds are ingredient- and method-aware: pass marks account for the analytical method used and its measurement uncertainty, rather than applying one borrowed number to everything.

A current third-party GMP certification (for example NSF, UL, USP, or Informed) covering dietary supplements, for the facility that actually makes the product, confirmed against the certifier's own record. A certificate for a different site does not transfer.
The manufacturer legal entity and the physical facility are identified and independently confirmed — business registry, certifier record, or site documentation. Self-declared only earns partial credit.
Lot coding, batch records, and a recall traceability procedure are documented for the formulation — so any bottle can be traced back to its batch.
A finished-product panel for lead, cadmium, inorganic arsenic, and mercury from an accredited laboratory, with every result inside the applicable limit (for example California Prop 65 or USP limits) for at least one tested batch. Any confirmed result over its limit is a fail — and a critical one.
A finished-product microbial panel — total plate count, yeast and mold, E. coli, Salmonella, Staphylococcus aureus as applicable — passes specification for at least one tested batch. A confirmed pathogen detection is a critical fail.
Screening matched to the ingredient risk profile — pesticides, residual solvents, undeclared pharmaceutical adulterants, or allergens — on file and passing. A panel that doesn't match the product's risks is inconclusive, not a pass.
Quantitative assay of the key active ingredients in a tested batch meets the label claim, within the tolerance for that ingredient and method and accounting for analytical uncertainty. A confirmed material shortfall is a critical fail.
Every printed claim — identity, potency, structure/function wording as printed — is matched claim by claim against assay reports or substantiation on file. Points follow the share covered; a claim contradicted by evidence is a fail.
The panel is complete — serving size, servings, amounts, percent daily values where required — and consistent with the tested formulation and assay results, for the exact label version sold.
The laboratories behind the relied-upon results hold ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation covering the methods used, current at the test date. Accreditation that doesn't cover a method used earns partial credit.
Complete original laboratory reports — methods, dates, sample identity, limits, analyst sign-off. Summary certificates and partial pages earn partial credit; screenshots earn none.
The issuing laboratory or certifier has confirmed the document is genuine — direct confirmation, a verification portal, or a verifiable report number. An altered or fabricated document is a critical failure and ends the evaluation as not verified.
The brand makes batch test results publicly accessible — on its website, via a QR code on the pack, or on request within a stated time. Results shared only after purchase earn partial credit.
The country and facility of manufacture are disclosed to consumers, on the label or the product page.
For brand-submitted evaluations: the brand supplied the requested documents and answered verification questions within the review window. This never applies to independent off-shelf evaluations, where non-cooperation must not lower a score.